 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Baseball League Forums » Dynasty Leagues » Dom DiMaggio League » new hall of fame hopefulls - please cast your vote
maxthesax
Players in caps are in their last year of eligibility (2006) is the current cut-off)
SP:
2012 Rick Starkel: SP 226-138 (54.5%) 1.22 whip (43) 3.64 era. 2507 k's (#66) and a 2.63 k/w ratio.
1x all star with 3 Cy Noms. 2x 20 gamer with 3 sub 3 era, and 2 sub 1.15 whip
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323225
2012 Sylvester Churchill: SP 181-168 (51.8%) 1.34 whip 3.91 era. 2851 k's (#24) 2.25 k/w ratio
3x all star with 1 cy nom, 1x 20 gamer with 1 sub 3 era. League leader in k's 2x.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9170699
2007 Frank Meloni: SP 256 (#25 all time) with 255 losses (50%ratio). finished with a 1.29 whip and a 3.62 era. His 3922 k's ranks #1 (2.3 k/w ratio).
6x allstar with 3 starts, had 2 gg, and had 2 cy noms. He posted 5 sub 3 era, 1 sub 1.15 whip, and had 1 20 game season. He holds the record for complete games (200!) and is #13 in shutouts. He was a league leader in shutouts 3x, complete games 2x, IP 6x, K's 6x, but with all those innings also led the league in BB, Earned runs 2x, and hits allowed. a real stat sheet filler!
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174959
2007 Hiro Nagasaki SP 203-142 (58,8% ratio) 1.32 whip and 3.89 era. 2680 k's ranks #33 (2.05 k/w ratio).
2x all star, 2 cy noms, 2 sub 3 era and 2 sub 1.15 whip with one 20 game win season.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=7620855
2007 Carl Petosky SP 201-202 (49%) while a 200 game loser, he posted a 1.29 whip and a 3.84 era. His 2933 k's ranks #18 and he had a fine 2.51 k/w ratio.
3x all star, gg winner, had 2 cy noms, posted 3 sub 3 era and 2 sub 1.15 whip and had one 20 game season.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698805
RP:
2012: Gene Olander: RP 118-66 (64%). era of 3.10 (#12 all time for pitchers with 1500 ip) whip 1.21 (#34 ditto). His 386 saves ranks #19 (was successful 79% of the time).
an 11x all star, cy young winner (with 5 noms) as well as receiving 3 fireman noms.
he saved 30 games 6x, had 5 sub 1.15 whips (one sub 1) and led the league in games played 3x.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323224
2010: Jason Tolleson: RP 115-73 (61%). era of 2.82 (#4 alltime for pitchers with at least 1500 ip) and his 1.10 whip stands at #5 (again for min 1500 ip).
he converted 254 saves (#38) at an 80% clip, while posting a 2.84 k/w/ ratio.
had 4 fireman nominations, while recording 3 30 save seasons, 10 sub 1.15 whips, 9 sub 3 era (1 sub 2).
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698815
2009: Jeff Mullen RP: 75-62 with a era of 3.0 and whip of 1.21. His 420 saves ranks # 13 (converting 83.6%).
8x allstar, won 2 fireman awards (and had 8 noms). He also garnered 2 cy young noms and was a league leader in saves while posting 4 40 save seasons.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174961
2008: Doug Schwabe RP 56-61 with a 3.62 era and a 1.34 whip. his 295 saves ranks #31 (posted a 79% ratio).
6x allstar, won a fireman award (3 noms). was a LL in saves, posted 4- 40 save seasons, had 2 sub 3 era and 1 sub 115 whip
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174978
Catchers:
2011: Charlie Guise: 281 ave. 5x Gold glover, had 4 300 ave seasons, 1 season with 100 rbi, was a ROY and was a league leader in ave and 2x lead in OB pct.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9555407
Infielders:
2012: Paul Cain: SS 275 ave with 235 hr, 1106 rbi and 1081 runs scored. Stole 280 bases at a 69% clip.
3x all star (1 start) and a MVP (with 2 noms) while also a GG winner.
he posted 1 300 season and 1 100 rbi campaign.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698839
2012 Jim Munoz: 2b: 266 ave with 305 hr, 1267 rbi and 1220 runs scored. Stole 253 bases (72% rate).
4x all; star, and 5x GG winner with 1 300 ave season.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8175044
2010: Alex Niarhos 1b: 285 ave with 219 hr, 832 rbi and 1347 runs scored. Stole 487 bases (#16) with a 77% success rate.
4x GG, 7x Allstar (a start), hit 300 4x, and scored 100 3x while stealing 40 bags 4x.
League leader in stolen bases 2x, ave,and ob pct
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8175022
2009: Bill Lawrence 1b: 280 ave with 288 hr, 1177 rbi and 1109 runs scored. Stole 207 bases (68% success rate).
2x GG, 5x allstar (2starts) hit 300 4x, had 1 100 rbi season and 1 100 runs scored campaign.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9021899
2009 Bill Tauscher SS: 289 ave with 241 hr, 931 rbi and 1348 runs scored. Stole 314 bases (66% success), is #58 in singles.
4x GG winner, 7x allstar(3starts), and won an MVP award.
Hit 300 2x, scored 100 runs 5x, had 1 40 steal season and was a league leader in steals and BB.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174994
2008: Bruce Krist 3b: 290 ave with 202 hr, 1055 rbi and 1431 runs scored. His 432 SB is #29 (71.8 ratio). Sits #29 in OBPCT, #68 in singles with 1706, #73 in 2b with 412 and #16 in BB.
3x GG winner, 7x AS (2 starts), LL in stolen bases. had 40 steals 3x, batted over 300 6x, and scored 100 runs 4x. Had 1 mvp nom.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=6983317
2008: Jim Dawson: ss: 273 ave with 381 HR (#42) 1278 rbi and 1246 runs scored. Stole 206 bases (68%).
2x GG, 7x AS (5 starts), MVP winner (2 noms), LL in hr, rbi, SB, SLG. Hit 300 3x, had 100 rbi 4x, 100 runs 3x hit 30 hrs 7x.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698812
2006: DENNIS SMITH 3b: 284 ave 389 hrs (#40) with 1455 rbi (#38).
6x allstar (4 starts) a GG winner, with 2 MVP noms. hit 3oo 4x, had 100 rbi 4x, 1oo runs 1x and hit 30 hr's
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=6983356
Outfielders:
2012" Hersh Sundin: of: 266 with 328 hrs, 1255 rbi and 1311 runs scored.
6x all star (3 starts) and was ROY.
he had 1 300 campaign, 1 30 hr and 1 100 rbi season and was a league leader in BB.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9021923
2011: Gomer LaCoss OF: 294 ave, 233 hr, 1113 runs scored. Stole 273 bases (70% success). won 2 Mvp awards, 1 gglove, a 2x allstar (2 starts). had 7 300 seasons, posted 3 550 slg pcts, had 3 400 obpcts, yet only scored 100 runs 1x. he was a League leader in ave, ob,and ops.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8483934
2009: Leo Morejon OF: 291 ave with 283 hr, 1134 rbi and 1060 runs scored. He swiped 300 bases (66% success).
3x GG, 4x allstar(2 starts), had 1mvp nom and was a ROY.
LL in ops, slg pct and ave he hit 300 4x, had 100 rbi 4x and had 1 season with 100 runs scored and 1 30 hr campaign.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8483957
2008: Jimmy Hartford OF: 265 ave with 326 hr, 1217 rbi and 1060 runs. Stole 237 bases (67.7 ratio).
1 GG, 3x AS, 1 MVP nom. ROY, LL in 3b. Had 1 30 hr season, 1 100 rbi
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=7385595
new hall of fame hopefulls - please cast your vote
August 13, 2014 at 08:40PM View BBCode
Just to review: you may vote for as many as 5 or as little as zero (as long as you declare that as your intention).Players in caps are in their last year of eligibility (2006) is the current cut-off)
SP:
2012 Rick Starkel: SP 226-138 (54.5%) 1.22 whip (43) 3.64 era. 2507 k's (#66) and a 2.63 k/w ratio.
1x all star with 3 Cy Noms. 2x 20 gamer with 3 sub 3 era, and 2 sub 1.15 whip
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323225
2012 Sylvester Churchill: SP 181-168 (51.8%) 1.34 whip 3.91 era. 2851 k's (#24) 2.25 k/w ratio
3x all star with 1 cy nom, 1x 20 gamer with 1 sub 3 era. League leader in k's 2x.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9170699
2007 Frank Meloni: SP 256 (#25 all time) with 255 losses (50%ratio). finished with a 1.29 whip and a 3.62 era. His 3922 k's ranks #1 (2.3 k/w ratio).
6x allstar with 3 starts, had 2 gg, and had 2 cy noms. He posted 5 sub 3 era, 1 sub 1.15 whip, and had 1 20 game season. He holds the record for complete games (200!) and is #13 in shutouts. He was a league leader in shutouts 3x, complete games 2x, IP 6x, K's 6x, but with all those innings also led the league in BB, Earned runs 2x, and hits allowed. a real stat sheet filler!
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174959
2007 Hiro Nagasaki SP 203-142 (58,8% ratio) 1.32 whip and 3.89 era. 2680 k's ranks #33 (2.05 k/w ratio).
2x all star, 2 cy noms, 2 sub 3 era and 2 sub 1.15 whip with one 20 game win season.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=7620855
2007 Carl Petosky SP 201-202 (49%) while a 200 game loser, he posted a 1.29 whip and a 3.84 era. His 2933 k's ranks #18 and he had a fine 2.51 k/w ratio.
3x all star, gg winner, had 2 cy noms, posted 3 sub 3 era and 2 sub 1.15 whip and had one 20 game season.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698805
RP:
2012: Gene Olander: RP 118-66 (64%). era of 3.10 (#12 all time for pitchers with 1500 ip) whip 1.21 (#34 ditto). His 386 saves ranks #19 (was successful 79% of the time).
an 11x all star, cy young winner (with 5 noms) as well as receiving 3 fireman noms.
he saved 30 games 6x, had 5 sub 1.15 whips (one sub 1) and led the league in games played 3x.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323224
2010: Jason Tolleson: RP 115-73 (61%). era of 2.82 (#4 alltime for pitchers with at least 1500 ip) and his 1.10 whip stands at #5 (again for min 1500 ip).
he converted 254 saves (#38) at an 80% clip, while posting a 2.84 k/w/ ratio.
had 4 fireman nominations, while recording 3 30 save seasons, 10 sub 1.15 whips, 9 sub 3 era (1 sub 2).
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698815
2009: Jeff Mullen RP: 75-62 with a era of 3.0 and whip of 1.21. His 420 saves ranks # 13 (converting 83.6%).
8x allstar, won 2 fireman awards (and had 8 noms). He also garnered 2 cy young noms and was a league leader in saves while posting 4 40 save seasons.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174961
2008: Doug Schwabe RP 56-61 with a 3.62 era and a 1.34 whip. his 295 saves ranks #31 (posted a 79% ratio).
6x allstar, won a fireman award (3 noms). was a LL in saves, posted 4- 40 save seasons, had 2 sub 3 era and 1 sub 115 whip
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174978
Catchers:
2011: Charlie Guise: 281 ave. 5x Gold glover, had 4 300 ave seasons, 1 season with 100 rbi, was a ROY and was a league leader in ave and 2x lead in OB pct.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9555407
Infielders:
2012: Paul Cain: SS 275 ave with 235 hr, 1106 rbi and 1081 runs scored. Stole 280 bases at a 69% clip.
3x all star (1 start) and a MVP (with 2 noms) while also a GG winner.
he posted 1 300 season and 1 100 rbi campaign.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698839
2012 Jim Munoz: 2b: 266 ave with 305 hr, 1267 rbi and 1220 runs scored. Stole 253 bases (72% rate).
4x all; star, and 5x GG winner with 1 300 ave season.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8175044
2010: Alex Niarhos 1b: 285 ave with 219 hr, 832 rbi and 1347 runs scored. Stole 487 bases (#16) with a 77% success rate.
4x GG, 7x Allstar (a start), hit 300 4x, and scored 100 3x while stealing 40 bags 4x.
League leader in stolen bases 2x, ave,and ob pct
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8175022
2009: Bill Lawrence 1b: 280 ave with 288 hr, 1177 rbi and 1109 runs scored. Stole 207 bases (68% success rate).
2x GG, 5x allstar (2starts) hit 300 4x, had 1 100 rbi season and 1 100 runs scored campaign.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9021899
2009 Bill Tauscher SS: 289 ave with 241 hr, 931 rbi and 1348 runs scored. Stole 314 bases (66% success), is #58 in singles.
4x GG winner, 7x allstar(3starts), and won an MVP award.
Hit 300 2x, scored 100 runs 5x, had 1 40 steal season and was a league leader in steals and BB.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174994
2008: Bruce Krist 3b: 290 ave with 202 hr, 1055 rbi and 1431 runs scored. His 432 SB is #29 (71.8 ratio). Sits #29 in OBPCT, #68 in singles with 1706, #73 in 2b with 412 and #16 in BB.
3x GG winner, 7x AS (2 starts), LL in stolen bases. had 40 steals 3x, batted over 300 6x, and scored 100 runs 4x. Had 1 mvp nom.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=6983317
2008: Jim Dawson: ss: 273 ave with 381 HR (#42) 1278 rbi and 1246 runs scored. Stole 206 bases (68%).
2x GG, 7x AS (5 starts), MVP winner (2 noms), LL in hr, rbi, SB, SLG. Hit 300 3x, had 100 rbi 4x, 100 runs 3x hit 30 hrs 7x.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698812
2006: DENNIS SMITH 3b: 284 ave 389 hrs (#40) with 1455 rbi (#38).
6x allstar (4 starts) a GG winner, with 2 MVP noms. hit 3oo 4x, had 100 rbi 4x, 1oo runs 1x and hit 30 hr's
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=6983356
Outfielders:
2012" Hersh Sundin: of: 266 with 328 hrs, 1255 rbi and 1311 runs scored.
6x all star (3 starts) and was ROY.
he had 1 300 campaign, 1 30 hr and 1 100 rbi season and was a league leader in BB.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9021923
2011: Gomer LaCoss OF: 294 ave, 233 hr, 1113 runs scored. Stole 273 bases (70% success). won 2 Mvp awards, 1 gglove, a 2x allstar (2 starts). had 7 300 seasons, posted 3 550 slg pcts, had 3 400 obpcts, yet only scored 100 runs 1x. he was a League leader in ave, ob,and ops.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8483934
2009: Leo Morejon OF: 291 ave with 283 hr, 1134 rbi and 1060 runs scored. He swiped 300 bases (66% success).
3x GG, 4x allstar(2 starts), had 1mvp nom and was a ROY.
LL in ops, slg pct and ave he hit 300 4x, had 100 rbi 4x and had 1 season with 100 runs scored and 1 30 hr campaign.
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8483957
2008: Jimmy Hartford OF: 265 ave with 326 hr, 1217 rbi and 1060 runs. Stole 237 bases (67.7 ratio).
1 GG, 3x AS, 1 MVP nom. ROY, LL in 3b. Had 1 30 hr season, 1 100 rbi
http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=7385595
Michael1
August 13, 2014 at 09:24PM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
Again No one.
curlin
Thanks for putting in the work!
Jake
August 15, 2014 at 12:43AM View BBCode
None of the above.Thanks for putting in the work!
Jake
spicoli306
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174959]Frank Merloni[/url]
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698815]Jason Tolleson[/url]
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323224]Gene Olander[/url]
Personally, I like an inclusive Hall of Fame. I can understand the ambivalence on the recent hitters, but there are some really good pitchers that are getting no support. I should probably even include Mullen (who was an elite closer), but I tend to leave guys off of my ballot when there are similar players that I believe were superior. Mullen has the counting stats of saves, but I think Tolleson and Olander had better careers.
On a side note, is there a reason you chose not to post your votes, max? If you are trying to avoid influencing other owners, I can understand. I think you should show your votes though, if only to add your voice as an owner that believes the HOF should include more than just the superstar players. BTW, you do a great job breaking down the nominees by giving good stat breakdowns like success rates and rankings among the all-time leaders. Thanks for putting this together.
August 15, 2014 at 06:02AM View BBCode
Cleveland votes for:[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174959]Frank Merloni[/url]
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698815]Jason Tolleson[/url]
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323224]Gene Olander[/url]
Personally, I like an inclusive Hall of Fame. I can understand the ambivalence on the recent hitters, but there are some really good pitchers that are getting no support. I should probably even include Mullen (who was an elite closer), but I tend to leave guys off of my ballot when there are similar players that I believe were superior. Mullen has the counting stats of saves, but I think Tolleson and Olander had better careers.
On a side note, is there a reason you chose not to post your votes, max? If you are trying to avoid influencing other owners, I can understand. I think you should show your votes though, if only to add your voice as an owner that believes the HOF should include more than just the superstar players. BTW, you do a great job breaking down the nominees by giving good stat breakdowns like success rates and rankings among the all-time leaders. Thanks for putting this together.
maxthesax
thanks for your comment. I enjoy taking a deeper look at the retiring players (and think that it adds another layer to the game to look at my own players and wonder if they are future HOF material).
as far as my own vote - you are correct; I don't want to influence any of the other managers, but if you cared to you can extrapolate my vote when I post the total tally. If you'd like, I will start posting my vote shortly before the deadline (and yes, my thoughts are similar to your own - a player like Tolleson just isn't getting the recognition he probably deserves... and I think that relievers in general are getting shorted (Mullen for example).
August 15, 2014 at 03:51PM View BBCode
Originally posted by spicoli306
Cleveland votes for:
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8174959]Frank Merloni[/url]
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=8698815]Jason Tolleson[/url]
[url=http://www.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=9323224]Gene Olander[/url]
Personally, I like an inclusive Hall of Fame. I can understand the ambivalence on the recent hitters, but there are some really good pitchers that are getting no support. I should probably even include Mullen (who was an elite closer), but I tend to leave guys off of my ballot when there are similar players that I believe were superior. Mullen has the counting stats of saves, but I think Tolleson and Olander had better careers.
On a side note, is there a reason you chose not to post your votes, max? If you are trying to avoid influencing other owners, I can understand. I think you should show your votes though, if only to add your voice as an owner that believes the HOF should include more than just the superstar players. BTW, you do a great job breaking down the nominees by giving good stat breakdowns like success rates and rankings among the all-time leaders. Thanks for putting this together.
thanks for your comment. I enjoy taking a deeper look at the retiring players (and think that it adds another layer to the game to look at my own players and wonder if they are future HOF material).
as far as my own vote - you are correct; I don't want to influence any of the other managers, but if you cared to you can extrapolate my vote when I post the total tally. If you'd like, I will start posting my vote shortly before the deadline (and yes, my thoughts are similar to your own - a player like Tolleson just isn't getting the recognition he probably deserves... and I think that relievers in general are getting shorted (Mullen for example).
maxthesax
and thank you for participating.
August 15, 2014 at 03:52PM View BBCode
Originally posted by curlin
None of the above.
Thanks for putting in the work!
Jake
and thank you for participating.
maxthesax
Frank Merloni
Jeff Mullen
Gene Olander
Jason Tolleson
Dennis Smith (last year of eligibility)
[Edited on 8-28-2014 by maxthesax]
August 28, 2014 at 09:53PM View BBCode
for the record: Baltimore votes for the followingFrank Merloni
Jeff Mullen
Gene Olander
Jason Tolleson
Dennis Smith (last year of eligibility)
[Edited on 8-28-2014 by maxthesax]
curlin
August 31, 2014 at 12:48AM View BBCode
After further review, I'd like to take back my "none of the above" and cast a vote for Jason Tolleson.
moondoggy75
Gene Olander
Jeff Mullen
Bruce Krist
Dennis Smith
August 31, 2014 at 05:15PM View BBCode
Frank MeloniGene Olander
Jeff Mullen
Bruce Krist
Dennis Smith
Pages: 1