 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Baseball League Forums » Dynasty Leagues » Billy Hamilton League » Post Season Awards ballot (for approval)
hbomb42
1. No voting for your own guys
2. Select your top three choices in order for each award.
MVP:
1.
2.
3.
Cy Young:
1.
2.
3.
Rookie of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Fireman Award:
1.
2.
3.
Manager of the Year (list team name):
1.
2.
3.
Does everyone pretty well agree to this format? We still have a couple of question that need to be answered.
1. Do we have a minimum number of votes to count this? (in other words do we need at least half the league to vote, 3/4?)
2. Are we going to post our votes, or do you want to u2u them to me for tabulation?
3. Do we only want to allow voting once the postseason starts, after it's over, or starting in game 140?
4. Do you want the top three or five results in each catagory?
5. Do you want to split the leagues into AL MVP and NL MVP, or just go league wide?
You guys chime in so I'll now how we want to approach this as a league. This could be pretty cool to have down the road. If it all works out, we'll keep a post running from year to year to update past winners.
Post Season Awards ballot (for approval)
October 28, 2003 at 07:12PM View BBCode
Basic Guidlines1. No voting for your own guys
2. Select your top three choices in order for each award.
MVP:
1.
2.
3.
Cy Young:
1.
2.
3.
Rookie of the Year:
1.
2.
3.
Fireman Award:
1.
2.
3.
Manager of the Year (list team name):
1.
2.
3.
Does everyone pretty well agree to this format? We still have a couple of question that need to be answered.
1. Do we have a minimum number of votes to count this? (in other words do we need at least half the league to vote, 3/4?)
2. Are we going to post our votes, or do you want to u2u them to me for tabulation?
3. Do we only want to allow voting once the postseason starts, after it's over, or starting in game 140?
4. Do you want the top three or five results in each catagory?
5. Do you want to split the leagues into AL MVP and NL MVP, or just go league wide?
You guys chime in so I'll now how we want to approach this as a league. This could be pretty cool to have down the road. If it all works out, we'll keep a post running from year to year to update past winners.
hbomb42
I think I'd like the public voting because I'm sure we all have slightly different standards on who deserves what. I think it would generate some good debate on the board after the voting is over.
I can go either way on top three verses top five. I'll post the point totals for each guy anyway, so we'll know how close it was.
I think we would need at least half of the league managers to vote. It seems that we have an active league as far working on the teams, but I've only noticed about half who actively post on the boards.
My thoughts are to vote once the postseason starts since we don't check our teams as often once the postseason is over.
My personal thoughts
October 28, 2003 at 07:20PM View BBCode
I think we should go league wide as far as the awards go. We don't have the number of teams that present day MLB has to need to split them. Plus it's the one way we can kinda compare players across divisional lines.I think I'd like the public voting because I'm sure we all have slightly different standards on who deserves what. I think it would generate some good debate on the board after the voting is over.
I can go either way on top three verses top five. I'll post the point totals for each guy anyway, so we'll know how close it was.
I think we would need at least half of the league managers to vote. It seems that we have an active league as far working on the teams, but I've only noticed about half who actively post on the boards.
My thoughts are to vote once the postseason starts since we don't check our teams as often once the postseason is over.
Meathead44
Combined
End of regular season
post or u2u makes no difference to me
October 29, 2003 at 07:10AM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
Well done.
Combined
End of regular season
post or u2u makes no difference to me
luv2bunt
Post season awards
October 29, 2003 at 01:51PM View BBCode
I think you did well. Lets get it on.:DPages: 1