 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Football League Forums » Premium (Multi-Season) Leagues » Vince Lombardi Football League » League Change Question
rileyh2008
League Change Question
September 04, 2014 at 07:05PM View BBCode
It does not pertain to this league, but i need to know percentage of vote is required for a league change. Thanks
rileyh2008
so in a 16 man league it had to be 13 yes's
September 04, 2014 at 08:23PM View BBCode
sent him a msg but i always thought it was 75%/+1so in a 16 man league it had to be 13 yes's
rileyh2008
September 04, 2014 at 08:28PM View BBCode
yea the forum admin said it was 50/+1 which im about 95% sure thats wrong.
dirtdevil
September 04, 2014 at 08:28PM View BBCode
I think it's also a % of the number voting, if unanimous is not required. so if the entire league votes you'd need 12 but if only half votes you only need 6.
rileyh2008
September 04, 2014 at 08:30PM View BBCode
guy flipping out in my league because i traded 2 4th's for a 31os elite Run blocker lol, i have made some one sided trades but certainly this isnt one lol.... a certain owner in our group thanks i got the bad end of the deal lol, but this guy is dead set on posing a cap because he thinks some how it will create balance and stop bad trades.
dirtdevil
yeah I think the whole thing is pretty hilarious. (not being in the league I can do that.) the guy is getting so worked up he wants to change the salary cap level over a deal where I think riley probably overpaid by a 4th rounder. :lol:
September 04, 2014 at 08:38PM View BBCode
Originally posted by rileyh2008
guy flipping out in my league because i traded 2 4th's for a 31os elite Run blocker lol, i have made some one sided trades but certainly this isnt one lol.... a certain owner in our group thanks i got the bad end of the deal lol, but this guy is dead set on posing a cap because he thinks some how it will create balance and stop bad trades.
yeah I think the whole thing is pretty hilarious. (not being in the league I can do that.) the guy is getting so worked up he wants to change the salary cap level over a deal where I think riley probably overpaid by a 4th rounder. :lol:
rileyh2008
September 04, 2014 at 08:40PM View BBCode
yea hes dead set that bringing a cap, will balance the league out....... I think i and shbo already posted it would do the exact opposite lol o well. I voted no because i built my roster for it the way it was but o well.
Admin
The overriding rule is that we don't like to change the rules out from under the feet of people who paid for a league based on the set of rules that was in place when they bought in. So for most things I impose a 66% or 75% majority, where if the vote isn't unanimous, implementation is delayed a couple of real-time months to allow those who disagree time to decide whether to renew under the new rules or not.
I am not sure I would use a salary cap to try to force trade equity. Trades are inherently unbalanced; it is the law of supply and demand, and no two players are ever absolutely equal. To get a valuable piece from another owner, you almost are REQUIRED to overpay because you need to make it worth his while to give up his bird in the hand for your two in the bush.
Chris
September 05, 2014 at 05:48PM View BBCode
The reason the answer is sometimes 75% and sometimes 66% and sometimes 50% is that we use different percentages based on how major the change is, plus we may also take into account how contentious a league is.The overriding rule is that we don't like to change the rules out from under the feet of people who paid for a league based on the set of rules that was in place when they bought in. So for most things I impose a 66% or 75% majority, where if the vote isn't unanimous, implementation is delayed a couple of real-time months to allow those who disagree time to decide whether to renew under the new rules or not.
I am not sure I would use a salary cap to try to force trade equity. Trades are inherently unbalanced; it is the law of supply and demand, and no two players are ever absolutely equal. To get a valuable piece from another owner, you almost are REQUIRED to overpay because you need to make it worth his while to give up his bird in the hand for your two in the bush.
Chris
rileyh2008
well here is the original post, im not sure thats how it goes lol..... He just decides what percent and how much it would be lol. Just wanted to call attention to it, because the entire thing doesn't seem to follow any sort of pecking order.
The reason im so apposed to it because as stated i signed up for the league, with a certain salary cap. The team was horrible and took there loses, then we built a power house and hes trying to reset it now.... Just doesnt seem just to me. anyways thanks for getting back to me Chris
September 05, 2014 at 05:59PM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
http://forum.simdynasty.com/viewthread.php?tid=393137&page=1
well here is the original post, im not sure thats how it goes lol..... He just decides what percent and how much it would be lol. Just wanted to call attention to it, because the entire thing doesn't seem to follow any sort of pecking order.
The reason im so apposed to it because as stated i signed up for the league, with a certain salary cap. The team was horrible and took there loses, then we built a power house and hes trying to reset it now.... Just doesnt seem just to me. anyways thanks for getting back to me Chris
EdSales87
Note to self, never join the EDFL, and add Geo to list of owners not to play with.
September 05, 2014 at 07:31PM View BBCode
I'm so glad I stumbled across those 2 threads in the EDFL.Note to self, never join the EDFL, and add Geo to list of owners not to play with.
dirtdevil
he's good entertainment, if nothing else. besides, anyone who's willing to give me a 2nd for a 30+ one-dimensional OL is welcome in my league anytime.
September 05, 2014 at 07:33PM View BBCode
Originally posted by EdSales87
I'm so glad I stumbled across those 2 threads in the EDFL.
Note to self, never join the EDFL, and add Geo to list of owners not to play with.
he's good entertainment, if nothing else. besides, anyone who's willing to give me a 2nd for a 30+ one-dimensional OL is welcome in my league anytime.
rileyh2008
September 05, 2014 at 09:32PM View BBCode
yea, at first i was amused.... then annoyed, now a bit pissed lolPages: 1