 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Football Beta Testing » Football Beta Test Discussion » Touchbacks
Fulla
1960- 256 touchbacks
1961- 282
1962- 400
1963- 482
1964- 178 thru 5 games
Touchbacks
September 10, 2011 at 02:23AM View BBCode
The Kickers are improving their leg strength at an alarming rate.1960- 256 touchbacks
1961- 282
1962- 400
1963- 482
1964- 178 thru 5 games
Fulla
September 10, 2011 at 02:44AM View BBCode
In the Walter Payton league there is an option to kick off from the 35 yd line. Soon there won't be any kick returns.
KLKRTR
September 10, 2011 at 07:38AM View BBCode
Atlanta certainly has improved...23 touchbacks in the first 4 seasons. 7 so far in 5 games now.
Fulla
September 10, 2011 at 01:07PM View BBCode
Chris, can you make the field bigger? Maybe 110 yards?
Admin
--Chris
September 10, 2011 at 03:35PM View BBCode
No, but you can set your kick returners to attempt returns from deeper into the end zone. The default is only 3 yards.--Chris
Admin
Kickers are more subject to talent inflation because only one good one is needed per team.
I'll taper off kickoff distance above a certain level so the best kickers are hitting touchbacks 50% of the time; right now a maxed out kicker can hit a touchback about 80% of the time. That will bring the average down to a reasonable level without affecting most kickers much at all.
--Chris
September 10, 2011 at 04:47PM View BBCode
Percentages started around 24% in 1960 to over 40% now.Kickers are more subject to talent inflation because only one good one is needed per team.
I'll taper off kickoff distance above a certain level so the best kickers are hitting touchbacks 50% of the time; right now a maxed out kicker can hit a touchback about 80% of the time. That will bring the average down to a reasonable level without affecting most kickers much at all.
--Chris
Admin
--Chris
September 10, 2011 at 04:48PM View BBCode
I think part of the problem is also more people starting to use their stronger-legged punters as kickoff specialists.--Chris
Admin
--Chris
September 13, 2011 at 03:00AM View BBCode
Touchbacks have come back down to earth after the changes... if you look at just the touchbacks since week 6 (pull the stas and then add &fromweek=6 to the URL) we look right on the money with the NFL. I'll be interested to watch how Beta unfolds to make sure the changes haven't adversely affected single-season leagues.--Chris
tworoosters
September 13, 2011 at 03:35AM View BBCode
I think this may have swung too far back the other way, in the past four weeks my 97 power kickoff man hasn't registered a touchback in 30 kickoffs and less than half his kickoffs are reaching inside the 10 yard line .
Admin
Power 97
Accuracy 59 (helps getting the best angle for longest distance)
Execution 10 (after Out of Position penalty, 39 before Out of Position penalty)
Simulating 100,000 kicks:
Longest kick: 88 yards
Shortest kick: 49 yards
Average: 72.2 yards
Touchbacks (deeper than 3 yards into end zone): 39.56%
Out of Bounds: 25
Kicks 85-89 yds: 209 (0.21%)
Kicks 80-84 yds: 2281 (2.28%)
Kicks 75-79 yds: 26565 (26.56%)
Kicks 70-74 yds: 45761 (45.76%)
Kicks 65-69 yds: 19560 (19.56%)
Kicks 60-64 yds: 4416 (4.42%)
Kicks 55-59 yds: 1076 (1.08%)
Kicks 50-54 yds: 131 (0.13%)
Kicks 45-49 yds: 1 (0.00%)
For comparison, the highest team touchback PCT in the NFL last year was 46.15% (Baltimore); the next highest was 31.18% (Oakland).
Note that the Out of Position penalty had little effect here; using his full Execution only brings his touchback % up to 39.9%. Execution is really only helpful on kickoff when it's higher than 50.
Plugging your actual kicker in, I'd get these results:
Longest: 87
Shortest: 48
Average: 70.7 yards
Touchback %: 29.523%
Out of Bounds: 2
Kicks 85-89 yds: 52 (0.05%)
Kicks 80-84 yds: 982 (0.98%)
Kicks 75-79 yds: 18740 (18.74%)
Kicks 70-74 yds: 42601 (42.60%)
Kicks 65-69 yds: 26607 (26.61%)
Kicks 60-64 yds: 8590 (8.59%)
Kicks 55-59 yds: 2212 (2.21%)
Kicks 50-54 yds: 210 (0.21%)
Kicks 45-49 yds: 6 (0.01%)
These assume perfect weather conditions, I haven't checked the weather of the games involved... but my instinct here says that your results are a smal sample size, but I would expect your kicker to get slightly better results than I am getting in my tester, and the Execution hit should be making a bigger difference.
--Chris
September 13, 2011 at 04:12AM View BBCode
Using punters as kickoff men can get inconsistent results as they take an out-of-position Execution hit. Let me plug him into my test page and see what we get:Power 97
Accuracy 59 (helps getting the best angle for longest distance)
Execution 10 (after Out of Position penalty, 39 before Out of Position penalty)
Simulating 100,000 kicks:
Longest kick: 88 yards
Shortest kick: 49 yards
Average: 72.2 yards
Touchbacks (deeper than 3 yards into end zone): 39.56%
Out of Bounds: 25
Kicks 85-89 yds: 209 (0.21%)
Kicks 80-84 yds: 2281 (2.28%)
Kicks 75-79 yds: 26565 (26.56%)
Kicks 70-74 yds: 45761 (45.76%)
Kicks 65-69 yds: 19560 (19.56%)
Kicks 60-64 yds: 4416 (4.42%)
Kicks 55-59 yds: 1076 (1.08%)
Kicks 50-54 yds: 131 (0.13%)
Kicks 45-49 yds: 1 (0.00%)
For comparison, the highest team touchback PCT in the NFL last year was 46.15% (Baltimore); the next highest was 31.18% (Oakland).
Note that the Out of Position penalty had little effect here; using his full Execution only brings his touchback % up to 39.9%. Execution is really only helpful on kickoff when it's higher than 50.
Plugging your actual kicker in, I'd get these results:
Longest: 87
Shortest: 48
Average: 70.7 yards
Touchback %: 29.523%
Out of Bounds: 2
Kicks 85-89 yds: 52 (0.05%)
Kicks 80-84 yds: 982 (0.98%)
Kicks 75-79 yds: 18740 (18.74%)
Kicks 70-74 yds: 42601 (42.60%)
Kicks 65-69 yds: 26607 (26.61%)
Kicks 60-64 yds: 8590 (8.59%)
Kicks 55-59 yds: 2212 (2.21%)
Kicks 50-54 yds: 210 (0.21%)
Kicks 45-49 yds: 6 (0.01%)
These assume perfect weather conditions, I haven't checked the weather of the games involved... but my instinct here says that your results are a smal sample size, but I would expect your kicker to get slightly better results than I am getting in my tester, and the Execution hit should be making a bigger difference.
--Chris
lancereisen
Changes were made regarding kickoffs to limit injuries. First, kickoffs will be moved from the 30 back up to the 35-yard line, repealing a 1994 rule change. In addition, players on the kickoff coverage team can not line up more than 5 yards behind the kickoff line, minimizing running starts and thus reducing the speed of collisions.[15] Other changes were also proposed, but a number of players and coaches expressed concern they would actually significantly reduce, if not eliminate, the number of kickoff returns.[16][17] Proposals that would have brought touchbacks out to the 25 instead of the 20, and eliminated all wedge blocks were not adopted.[15] Despite this rule, the Bears kicked off from the 30-yard line twice in their preseason game against the Bills until the league forced them to stop.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_NFL_season#Rule_changes
September 13, 2011 at 04:46AM View BBCode
The following are rule changes that were passed at the league's annual owners meeting in March. All changes went into effect once the labor dispute was resolved.Changes were made regarding kickoffs to limit injuries. First, kickoffs will be moved from the 30 back up to the 35-yard line, repealing a 1994 rule change. In addition, players on the kickoff coverage team can not line up more than 5 yards behind the kickoff line, minimizing running starts and thus reducing the speed of collisions.[15] Other changes were also proposed, but a number of players and coaches expressed concern they would actually significantly reduce, if not eliminate, the number of kickoff returns.[16][17] Proposals that would have brought touchbacks out to the 25 instead of the 20, and eliminated all wedge blocks were not adopted.[15] Despite this rule, the Bears kicked off from the 30-yard line twice in their preseason game against the Bills until the league forced them to stop.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_NFL_season#Rule_changes
tworoosters
This brings up another issue, why is he receiving an out of position penalty ?
Kickoffs are separate from FG/PAT and [url=http://footballbeta.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=128072]Trebotich[/url] is higher rated as a KOS (83) than as a P (71) in fact KOS is his best role.
Also prior to his recent 0/30 Trebotich was just over 33.6 % on touchbacks for his career which seems in line .
September 13, 2011 at 05:26AM View BBCode
Originally posted by Admin
Using punters as kickoff men can get inconsistent results as they take an out-of-position Execution hit. Let me plug him into my test page and see what we get:
Power 97
Accuracy 59 (helps getting the best angle for longest distance)
Execution 10 (after Out of Position penalty, 39 before Out of Position penalty)
This brings up another issue, why is he receiving an out of position penalty ?
Kickoffs are separate from FG/PAT and [url=http://footballbeta.simdynasty.com/player.jsp?id=128072]Trebotich[/url] is higher rated as a KOS (83) than as a P (71) in fact KOS is his best role.
Also prior to his recent 0/30 Trebotich was just over 33.6 % on touchbacks for his career which seems in line .
Admin
If his career results were just over 33.6% I have to wonder if there's another factor at work here, 'cause I'd have expected him to be higher.
I've increased the kick lengths a bit but I'm going to continue to look at this.
--Chris
September 13, 2011 at 02:00PM View BBCode
That 83 KOS rating is after his out-of-position penalty. KOS requires a lot of power, so anyone with high Power and lower at other skills will likely be rated with KKOS as their highest rating... for this reason, KOS no longer shows up in the Best Role column (because most Punters have KOS rated higher even after penalties).If his career results were just over 33.6% I have to wonder if there's another factor at work here, 'cause I'd have expected him to be higher.
I've increased the kick lengths a bit but I'm going to continue to look at this.
--Chris
RichNYC1
Chris, can you make the field bigger? Maybe 110 yards? [/quote]
I think thats a great idea since the game plays like the CFL anyway ;)
September 13, 2011 at 02:11PM View formatted
You are viewing the raw post code; this allows you to copy a message with BBCode formatting intact.
[quote][i]Originally posted by Fulla[/i]
Chris, can you make the field bigger? Maybe 110 yards? [/quote]
I think thats a great idea since the game plays like the CFL anyway ;)
tworoosters
OK, but you've gotta make it wider and go with three downs then.
September 13, 2011 at 02:55PM View BBCode
Originally posted by RichNYC1
Originally posted by Fulla
Chris, can you make the field bigger? Maybe 110 yards?
I think that's a great idea since the game plays like the CFL anyway ;)
OK, but you've gotta make it wider and go with three downs then.
tworoosters
The wider field, three downs and motion allowed would make the game simply amazing to watch .
September 13, 2011 at 05:33PM View BBCode
Actually I truly believe that if the CFL game was played by NFL caliber athletes it would be the greatest football ever.The wider field, three downs and motion allowed would make the game simply amazing to watch .
Admin
September 13, 2011 at 05:40PM View BBCode
Hm. I wonder how hard it would be to add a CFL ruleset as a league option....
redcped
September 13, 2011 at 06:48PM View BBCode
You've already got the cities in there. We could test a couple seasons in Beta if you can do it. Would be a blast.
tworoosters
How would AFE react to the 110*65 field with 20 yard endzones ?
September 13, 2011 at 07:25PM View BBCode
It's not just the rules it's the field.How would AFE react to the 110*65 field with 20 yard endzones ?
Admin
That's the thing, there are so many assumptions in the code of a 100 yard field, it's not done as a variable. Plus DynastyVision graphics would allneed to be redone in the larger size.
--Chris
September 13, 2011 at 07:55PM View BBCode
Originally posted by tworoosters
It's not just the rules it's the field.
How would AFE react to the 110*65 field with 20 yard endzones ?
That's the thing, there are so many assumptions in the code of a 100 yard field, it's not done as a variable. Plus DynastyVision graphics would allneed to be redone in the larger size.
--Chris
Pages: 1