 |
View Old Forum Thread
Old Forum Index » Baseball League Forums » Speed Leagues » Ted Williams League » Nuzzy's prospects report
nuzzy62
1 San diego
3 New York Am, Texas, San Francisco
5 Florida
6 Seattle
7 Pittsburgh
10 Anaheim
14 Los Angeles AM, Minnesota
17 Chicago
25 Atlanta
26 Cincinnati
39 Detroit Congrats Todd! Cincy also looks strong with lots of starting pitching.
2154 Farm System of the Year
August 27, 2015 at 11:53PM View BBCode
0 New York Nat1 San diego
3 New York Am, Texas, San Francisco
5 Florida
6 Seattle
7 Pittsburgh
10 Anaheim
14 Los Angeles AM, Minnesota
17 Chicago
25 Atlanta
26 Cincinnati
39 Detroit Congrats Todd! Cincy also looks strong with lots of starting pitching.
todd999430
Thanks for doing these rankings, nuzzy. It is appreciated.
August 28, 2015 at 12:05AM View BBCode
Two years in a row. Just need to sell off some of these pieces so I can pretend to contend now.Thanks for doing these rankings, nuzzy. It is appreciated.
nuzzy62
17: 1. Poorboy Harris C LAN
18: 1. Claude Zauchin B- CHA; 2. Bernie Molitor B- DET; 3. John Castillo C+ NYA
19: 1. Bill Cantwell C+ LAA
20: 1. Dad Schmitz B LAA; 2. Juan Jones NYA B; 3. Humpty Overalls C, LAN
21: 1. John Lopez B MIN; 2. Allie See B CIN; 3. Harry Mizeur B DET
22: 1. Tim Overland A- DET; 2. John Davis B SEA; 3. Jim Hampton B NYN
Relief Pitchers
17: 1. Junior Morarty C+ LAN; 2. Ed Fortune C SEA; 3. Bob Comstock Cin
18: 1. Abner Reinecker B SF; 2. Leon Phillips C+ SF; 3. Vince Haines C+ SF
19: 1. Mike Brady B- ATL; 2. Bass Fisher B-, LAN; 3. Jim Lange SF
20: 1. Tom Williams B- CHA; 2. Keith Gilbert C NYN; 3. Bob Madison C- ATL
21: 1. Kershaw Nuzzy B LAN; 2. Schoolboy Hamilton B- LAN; 3. Frank Driscoll B- SEA
22: 1. Babe Burgess B+ LAN; 2. Dick Golvin B- SD; 3. Ben Synder B- SD;
Position Players
17: 1. Garry DeLeon C SF; 2. Troy Doyle C Tes; 3. ShakyLegs Williams C LAN
18: 1. Dustin Robinson C+ ANA; 2. Ed Howell C Cin; 3. Luis Ashby C+ DET; 4. Ed Wolfgang C+ MIN
19: 1. Orlando Lindquist C+ CIN; 2. Dusty Walker C CIN; 3. Ray McWeeny C+ ATL; 4. Fred Browning C+ CIN; 5. John Hiatt C+ DET
20: 1. Ron Saunders C+ SD; 2. Bobby Harrison B- CHA; 3. George Sanchez B- SF; 4. PeeWee Fowler B- LAN; 5. Frank Rodgers B- CHA
21: 1. Ed Marrow B+ ATL; 2. Stan Norton CHA B; 3. Spencer Ewing B DET; 4. Todd Staley B- LAN; 5. Jack Eaton B- MIN
22: 1. Luis Nixon B+ ATL; 2. Eric Fish B+ CIN; 3. Jock Carter B DET; 4. 45 Rich B LAN; 5. Dick Croushore B CHA
2156 prospects report
September 20, 2015 at 09:34PM View BBCode
Starting Pitchers17: 1. Poorboy Harris C LAN
18: 1. Claude Zauchin B- CHA; 2. Bernie Molitor B- DET; 3. John Castillo C+ NYA
19: 1. Bill Cantwell C+ LAA
20: 1. Dad Schmitz B LAA; 2. Juan Jones NYA B; 3. Humpty Overalls C, LAN
21: 1. John Lopez B MIN; 2. Allie See B CIN; 3. Harry Mizeur B DET
22: 1. Tim Overland A- DET; 2. John Davis B SEA; 3. Jim Hampton B NYN
Relief Pitchers
17: 1. Junior Morarty C+ LAN; 2. Ed Fortune C SEA; 3. Bob Comstock Cin
18: 1. Abner Reinecker B SF; 2. Leon Phillips C+ SF; 3. Vince Haines C+ SF
19: 1. Mike Brady B- ATL; 2. Bass Fisher B-, LAN; 3. Jim Lange SF
20: 1. Tom Williams B- CHA; 2. Keith Gilbert C NYN; 3. Bob Madison C- ATL
21: 1. Kershaw Nuzzy B LAN; 2. Schoolboy Hamilton B- LAN; 3. Frank Driscoll B- SEA
22: 1. Babe Burgess B+ LAN; 2. Dick Golvin B- SD; 3. Ben Synder B- SD;
Position Players
17: 1. Garry DeLeon C SF; 2. Troy Doyle C Tes; 3. ShakyLegs Williams C LAN
18: 1. Dustin Robinson C+ ANA; 2. Ed Howell C Cin; 3. Luis Ashby C+ DET; 4. Ed Wolfgang C+ MIN
19: 1. Orlando Lindquist C+ CIN; 2. Dusty Walker C CIN; 3. Ray McWeeny C+ ATL; 4. Fred Browning C+ CIN; 5. John Hiatt C+ DET
20: 1. Ron Saunders C+ SD; 2. Bobby Harrison B- CHA; 3. George Sanchez B- SF; 4. PeeWee Fowler B- LAN; 5. Frank Rodgers B- CHA
21: 1. Ed Marrow B+ ATL; 2. Stan Norton CHA B; 3. Spencer Ewing B DET; 4. Todd Staley B- LAN; 5. Jack Eaton B- MIN
22: 1. Luis Nixon B+ ATL; 2. Eric Fish B+ CIN; 3. Jock Carter B DET; 4. 45 Rich B LAN; 5. Dick Croushore B CHA
nuzzy62
0 Florida, Pittsburgh
2 NYA
4 NYN
5 Texas
7 Anaheim, Seattle
8 Minny
10 LAA
11 SD
19 Detroit
20 San Fran
22 Chicago
23 Atlanta
28 Cincy
36 LAN
2156 Farm System of the year
September 20, 2015 at 09:44PM View BBCode
(Overall it looks pretty weak compared to other years)0 Florida, Pittsburgh
2 NYA
4 NYN
5 Texas
7 Anaheim, Seattle
8 Minny
10 LAA
11 SD
19 Detroit
20 San Fran
22 Chicago
23 Atlanta
28 Cincy
36 LAN
nuzzy62
20: 1. Ron Saunders C+ SD; 2. Bobby Harrison B- CHA; 3. George Sanchez B- SF; 4. PeeWee Fowler B- LAN; 5. Frank Rodgers B- CHA
I liked Saunders slight power advantage over the B- guys. I also considered Tom Jackson who had a C-/A- right split but he also has C- speed which will probably make him too slow for the majors.
There were no players with blue and or red splits on the right.
Here are the B- guys
CvR/PvR/SP
Harrison B/C+/C+
Sanchez C/B-/B-
Fowler B/C+/A
Rodgers C-/B-/A
Brusstar B-/C+/B
Hastings C+/C-/A+
---
Saunders C-/B/B+
I just did a quick read and in retrospect, I rated Harrison too high.
Of the B- guys, it probably should be Fowler, Rodgers, Brusstar, Sanchez, Harrison and Hastings.
How would you have ranked them?
September 20, 2015 at 11:34PM View BBCode
Originally posted by todd999430
no Brustar at 20yo? why is a C+ guy first?
20: 1. Ron Saunders C+ SD; 2. Bobby Harrison B- CHA; 3. George Sanchez B- SF; 4. PeeWee Fowler B- LAN; 5. Frank Rodgers B- CHA
I liked Saunders slight power advantage over the B- guys. I also considered Tom Jackson who had a C-/A- right split but he also has C- speed which will probably make him too slow for the majors.
There were no players with blue and or red splits on the right.
Here are the B- guys
CvR/PvR/SP
Harrison B/C+/C+
Sanchez C/B-/B-
Fowler B/C+/A
Rodgers C-/B-/A
Brusstar B-/C+/B
Hastings C+/C-/A+
---
Saunders C-/B/B+
I just did a quick read and in retrospect, I rated Harrison too high.
Of the B- guys, it probably should be Fowler, Rodgers, Brusstar, Sanchez, Harrison and Hastings.
How would you have ranked them?
todd999430
so i just rely on your rankings.
RECOUNT!
September 21, 2015 at 07:33PM View BBCode
truthfully, i don't have anywhere near the amount of time i'd need to do what you do.so i just rely on your rankings.
RECOUNT!
nuzzy62
17: 1. Wally Mead SF C; 2. Valmy Taylor CHA C+; 3. Winn Dixie LAN C
18: 1. Poorboy Harris LAN C+; 2. Barry Hernandez SF C
19: 1. Bernie Molitor DET B; 2. Claude Zauchin CHA B-; 3. Snake Plissken LAN C+
20: 1. Bill Cantwell LAA C+; 2. Mike Carey SD C; 3. Scott Miller ATL C
21: 1. Oscar Robertson NYN B-; 2. Dad Schmitz LAA B; 3. Humpty Overalls LAN B-
22: 1. Juan Lopez MIN B+; 2. Allie See CIN B+; 3. Shannon McCullough ATL B;
Relief Pitching
17: None
18: 1. Junior Moriarty LAN B-; 2. Bob Comstock CIN B-; 3. Ed Fortune SEA
19: 1. Tom Heaton SEA B+; 2. C+Abner Reinecker SF B; 3. Leon Phillips SEA B-
20: 1. Mike Brady ATL B-; 2. Bass Fisher LAN B; 3. Jim Lange SF B-
21: 1. Tom Williams CHA B; 2. Bill Brown LAA B-; 3. Jeff Blaylock NYN C+
22: 1. Kershaw Nuzzy LAN B; 2. Hilton Hernandez CIN B; 3. Chet Cooper ANA B
Position players
17: 1. Eric McCardell FLA C+; 2. Rip Madison DET C; 3. Bill JOhnson ANA C; 4. Mario Walker CIN C; 5. Mike Ezell SF C-
18: 1. Carl Wilkins CIN C+; 2. Garry DeLeon SF C+; 3. Troy Doyle TEX C; 4. Casey AtBat LAN C; 5. ShakeyLegs Williams LAN C+
19: 1. Dustin Robinson ANA B-; 2. Luis Ashby DET B-; 3. Ed Wolfgang MIN B-; 4. Pat Sadowski SD C+; 5. Ed Howell CIN C
20: 1. Ray McWeeny ATL B-; 2. Dusty Walker CIN C+; 3. Orlando Lindquist CIN C+; 4. Fred Browning CIN B-; 5. Davis Benjamin ANA B-
21: 1. Mike Brusstar DET B; 2. Bobby Harrison CHA B-; 3. Frank Rodgers SF B; 4. Tom Jackson CHA B-; 5. Frank Sloan FLA B-
22: 1. Stan Norton CHA B+; 2. Jim Milner SD B+; 3. Ed Marrow ATL B+; 4. Todd Staley LAN B; 5. Jack Eaton MIN B
[Edited on 10-3-2015 by nuzzy62]
2157 Prospects Report
October 02, 2015 at 11:44PM View BBCode
Starting Pitching17: 1. Wally Mead SF C; 2. Valmy Taylor CHA C+; 3. Winn Dixie LAN C
18: 1. Poorboy Harris LAN C+; 2. Barry Hernandez SF C
19: 1. Bernie Molitor DET B; 2. Claude Zauchin CHA B-; 3. Snake Plissken LAN C+
20: 1. Bill Cantwell LAA C+; 2. Mike Carey SD C; 3. Scott Miller ATL C
21: 1. Oscar Robertson NYN B-; 2. Dad Schmitz LAA B; 3. Humpty Overalls LAN B-
22: 1. Juan Lopez MIN B+; 2. Allie See CIN B+; 3. Shannon McCullough ATL B;
Relief Pitching
17: None
18: 1. Junior Moriarty LAN B-; 2. Bob Comstock CIN B-; 3. Ed Fortune SEA
19: 1. Tom Heaton SEA B+; 2. C+Abner Reinecker SF B; 3. Leon Phillips SEA B-
20: 1. Mike Brady ATL B-; 2. Bass Fisher LAN B; 3. Jim Lange SF B-
21: 1. Tom Williams CHA B; 2. Bill Brown LAA B-; 3. Jeff Blaylock NYN C+
22: 1. Kershaw Nuzzy LAN B; 2. Hilton Hernandez CIN B; 3. Chet Cooper ANA B
Position players
17: 1. Eric McCardell FLA C+; 2. Rip Madison DET C; 3. Bill JOhnson ANA C; 4. Mario Walker CIN C; 5. Mike Ezell SF C-
18: 1. Carl Wilkins CIN C+; 2. Garry DeLeon SF C+; 3. Troy Doyle TEX C; 4. Casey AtBat LAN C; 5. ShakeyLegs Williams LAN C+
19: 1. Dustin Robinson ANA B-; 2. Luis Ashby DET B-; 3. Ed Wolfgang MIN B-; 4. Pat Sadowski SD C+; 5. Ed Howell CIN C
20: 1. Ray McWeeny ATL B-; 2. Dusty Walker CIN C+; 3. Orlando Lindquist CIN C+; 4. Fred Browning CIN B-; 5. Davis Benjamin ANA B-
21: 1. Mike Brusstar DET B; 2. Bobby Harrison CHA B-; 3. Frank Rodgers SF B; 4. Tom Jackson CHA B-; 5. Frank Sloan FLA B-
22: 1. Stan Norton CHA B+; 2. Jim Milner SD B+; 3. Ed Marrow ATL B+; 4. Todd Staley LAN B; 5. Jack Eaton MIN B
[Edited on 10-3-2015 by nuzzy62]
nuzzy62
3 TEX
5 SD
6 NYN
7 SEA
8 Florida
9 Minny
11 LAA
12 Anaheim
17 Atlanta
22 Detroit
25 Chicago
26 LAN, San Fran
29 Cincy Congrats MetFan!
2157 Farm System of the Year
October 03, 2015 at 12:01AM View BBCode
0 NYA, PIT3 TEX
5 SD
6 NYN
7 SEA
8 Florida
9 Minny
11 LAA
12 Anaheim
17 Atlanta
22 Detroit
25 Chicago
26 LAN, San Fran
29 Cincy Congrats MetFan!
todd999430
Also, the second place guy isn't C-, is he?
Have you thought of a formula to combine the prospects ratings and the other thread ratings you do to get an overall "state of the franchise" rating?
October 03, 2015 at 12:04AM View BBCode
Brussie goes from unmentioned to 1st in his age ranking. Interesting.Also, the second place guy isn't C-, is he?
Have you thought of a formula to combine the prospects ratings and the other thread ratings you do to get an overall "state of the franchise" rating?
nuzzy62
17: 1. George Taylor Cin C+; 2. Jim Snipes NYA C
18: 1. Ryne Brown LAA B-; 2. Charlie Brower NYA C
19: 1. Wally Mead SF B-; 2. Valmy Taylor CHA B-; 3. Winn Dixie LAN B
20: 1. Poorboy Harris LAN B-; 2. John Dorman Min C; 3. Pembroke Yarnell MIN C+
21: 1. Bernie Molitor DET B+; 2. Rich 45 Jr. LAN B; 3. Claude Zauchin CHA B
22: 1. Bill Cantwell LAA B; 2. Nanny Lindaman SF B+; 3. Mike Carey SD B-
Relief pitchers
17: None
18: 1. Thumper Williams LAN B-; 2. Charley McGraner NYA C+
19: 1. Paddy Hasty FLA C+; 2. Scott Tate MIN C; 3. Slick Street LAN C+
20: 1. Junior Moriarty LAN B+; 2. Bob Comstock CIN B+; 3. Ed Fortune SEA B-
21: 1. Tom Heaton SEA B+; 2. Abner Reinecker SF B+; 3. Vince Haines SF B
22: 1. Mike Brady ATL B; 2. Bass Fisher LAN B+; 3. Sal Swigler MIN B-
Position players
17: 1. Shoeless Daniels LAN C; 2. Floyd Dingman NYN C; 3. Dave DeSilva MIN C; 4. Junior Reynolds FLA C; 5. Scott Aker LAA C
18: 1. Joe Tracewski LAA B-; 2. Bud Gladd ATL C+; 3. Dusty Stahl NYA C; 4. Hector Gerner DET C; 5. Pushcart Archer LAN C
19: 1. Sabata McCardell DET B-; 2. Rip Madison DET B-; 3. Tenley Bargot ATL B-; 4. Tim McCormick CIN C+; 5. Mario Walker CIN B-
20: 1. Frank Wright PIT B; 2. Casey ATBat LAN B-; 3. Carl Wilkins CIN B; 4. Al Nettles SEA B-; Garry DeLeon SF B-
21: 1. Dustin Robinson ANA B; 2. Pat Sadowski SD B; 3. Steve McGraw CIN B; 4. Ed Wolfgang MIN B; 5. Clyde Locklin NYN B-
22: 1. Luis Aparicio Jr ATL B; 2. Beiker Weber CIN B; 3. Fred Browning CIN B; 4. Davis Benjamin ANA B; 5. John Hiatt DET B
[Edited on 10-26-2015 by nuzzy62]
2159 Prospects Report
October 26, 2015 at 09:58PM View BBCode
Starting pitchers17: 1. George Taylor Cin C+; 2. Jim Snipes NYA C
18: 1. Ryne Brown LAA B-; 2. Charlie Brower NYA C
19: 1. Wally Mead SF B-; 2. Valmy Taylor CHA B-; 3. Winn Dixie LAN B
20: 1. Poorboy Harris LAN B-; 2. John Dorman Min C; 3. Pembroke Yarnell MIN C+
21: 1. Bernie Molitor DET B+; 2. Rich 45 Jr. LAN B; 3. Claude Zauchin CHA B
22: 1. Bill Cantwell LAA B; 2. Nanny Lindaman SF B+; 3. Mike Carey SD B-
Relief pitchers
17: None
18: 1. Thumper Williams LAN B-; 2. Charley McGraner NYA C+
19: 1. Paddy Hasty FLA C+; 2. Scott Tate MIN C; 3. Slick Street LAN C+
20: 1. Junior Moriarty LAN B+; 2. Bob Comstock CIN B+; 3. Ed Fortune SEA B-
21: 1. Tom Heaton SEA B+; 2. Abner Reinecker SF B+; 3. Vince Haines SF B
22: 1. Mike Brady ATL B; 2. Bass Fisher LAN B+; 3. Sal Swigler MIN B-
Position players
17: 1. Shoeless Daniels LAN C; 2. Floyd Dingman NYN C; 3. Dave DeSilva MIN C; 4. Junior Reynolds FLA C; 5. Scott Aker LAA C
18: 1. Joe Tracewski LAA B-; 2. Bud Gladd ATL C+; 3. Dusty Stahl NYA C; 4. Hector Gerner DET C; 5. Pushcart Archer LAN C
19: 1. Sabata McCardell DET B-; 2. Rip Madison DET B-; 3. Tenley Bargot ATL B-; 4. Tim McCormick CIN C+; 5. Mario Walker CIN B-
20: 1. Frank Wright PIT B; 2. Casey ATBat LAN B-; 3. Carl Wilkins CIN B; 4. Al Nettles SEA B-; Garry DeLeon SF B-
21: 1. Dustin Robinson ANA B; 2. Pat Sadowski SD B; 3. Steve McGraw CIN B; 4. Ed Wolfgang MIN B; 5. Clyde Locklin NYN B-
22: 1. Luis Aparicio Jr ATL B; 2. Beiker Weber CIN B; 3. Fred Browning CIN B; 4. Davis Benjamin ANA B; 5. John Hiatt DET B
[Edited on 10-26-2015 by nuzzy62]
nuzzy62
4 Chicago
6 NYN, San Diego
7 Pittsburgh, Florida
8 Seattle
9 Anaheim
12 NYA
13 Minnesota, San Francisco
18 LAA
20 Detroit, Atlanta
25 Cincinnati
36 LAN Congrats to me.
:D
2159 Farm System of the Year
October 26, 2015 at 10:08PM View BBCode
0 Texas4 Chicago
6 NYN, San Diego
7 Pittsburgh, Florida
8 Seattle
9 Anaheim
12 NYA
13 Minnesota, San Francisco
18 LAA
20 Detroit, Atlanta
25 Cincinnati
36 LAN Congrats to me.
:D
nuzzy62
17: 1. Bulldog Howse, LAN B-; 2. Dave Evans Tex C
18: None
19: 1. George Taylor Cin B; 2. Roy Narleski Det B-; 3. Jim Snipes NYA C+
20: 1. Ryne Brown LAA B; 2. Charlie Brower NYA B-; 3. Buck Munoz SD C
21: 1. Wally Mead SF B+; 2. Winn Dixie LAN B+; 3. Valmy Taylor Cha B
22: 1. Poorboy Harris LAN B+; 2. Craig Kehn NYN B-; 3. John Dorman Atl B-
Relief Pitchers
17: 1. Johnny Gray NYA C; 2. Chippy Duffy NYA C
18: 1, Fritz Bench Cin B; Germiko Hill LAN B-; 3. Kent Orsino NYA C
19: 1. Bobby Cassidy NYA B-; 2. Tommy Mays LAN C
20: 1. Thumper Williams LAN B; 2. Charley McGraner NYA B; 3. Jesse Bradford NYA C+
21: 1. Paddy Hasty Fla B-; 2. Scott Tate Min B-; 3. Bill Rivers SD C+
22: 1. 1. Junior Moriarty LAN A-; 2. Ed Fortune Sea B+; 3. Bob Comstock Cin B+
Position players
17: 1. Bucket Goldbullion Fla B-; 2. Greg Valentinetti LAA C+; 3. Pelham Callahan Sea C; 4. Lefty Kessler Tex C+; 5. Dunlow Firebang Fla C
18: 1. Mike Zick Cin C+; 2. Lloyd Hudson Cha C+; 3. Dave Ramirez LAA C; 4. Allen Gelbert tex C; 5. Bob Boone Cin C+
19: 1. Floyd Dingman NYN C+; 2. Shoeless Daniels LAN B-; 3. Lerton Smith Det B-; 4. Dave DeSilva Ana B-; 5. Benito Liptackle Fla C
20: 1. Joe Tracewski LAA B; 2. Guy Kozar Cha C+; 3. Bud Gladd Ana B-; 4. Hector Gerner Det C+; 5. Pushcart Archer LAN C+
21: 1. Mike Cook SF B; 2. Sabata McCardell Det B; 3. Wattie Needham SF B; 4. Rip Madison Det B; 5. Tenley Bargot Ana B
22: 1. Frank Wright Pit B+; 2. Jerry Johnson NYA B+; 3. Carl Wilkins Cin B+; 4. Al Nettles Sea B; 5. Jack Smith NYN B
[Edited on 11-20-2015 by nuzzy62]
[Edited on 11-20-2015 by nuzzy62]
[Edited on 11-20-2015 by nuzzy62]
2161 Prospects report
November 20, 2015 at 02:12PM View BBCode
Starting Pitchers17: 1. Bulldog Howse, LAN B-; 2. Dave Evans Tex C
18: None
19: 1. George Taylor Cin B; 2. Roy Narleski Det B-; 3. Jim Snipes NYA C+
20: 1. Ryne Brown LAA B; 2. Charlie Brower NYA B-; 3. Buck Munoz SD C
21: 1. Wally Mead SF B+; 2. Winn Dixie LAN B+; 3. Valmy Taylor Cha B
22: 1. Poorboy Harris LAN B+; 2. Craig Kehn NYN B-; 3. John Dorman Atl B-
Relief Pitchers
17: 1. Johnny Gray NYA C; 2. Chippy Duffy NYA C
18: 1, Fritz Bench Cin B; Germiko Hill LAN B-; 3. Kent Orsino NYA C
19: 1. Bobby Cassidy NYA B-; 2. Tommy Mays LAN C
20: 1. Thumper Williams LAN B; 2. Charley McGraner NYA B; 3. Jesse Bradford NYA C+
21: 1. Paddy Hasty Fla B-; 2. Scott Tate Min B-; 3. Bill Rivers SD C+
22: 1. 1. Junior Moriarty LAN A-; 2. Ed Fortune Sea B+; 3. Bob Comstock Cin B+
Position players
17: 1. Bucket Goldbullion Fla B-; 2. Greg Valentinetti LAA C+; 3. Pelham Callahan Sea C; 4. Lefty Kessler Tex C+; 5. Dunlow Firebang Fla C
18: 1. Mike Zick Cin C+; 2. Lloyd Hudson Cha C+; 3. Dave Ramirez LAA C; 4. Allen Gelbert tex C; 5. Bob Boone Cin C+
19: 1. Floyd Dingman NYN C+; 2. Shoeless Daniels LAN B-; 3. Lerton Smith Det B-; 4. Dave DeSilva Ana B-; 5. Benito Liptackle Fla C
20: 1. Joe Tracewski LAA B; 2. Guy Kozar Cha C+; 3. Bud Gladd Ana B-; 4. Hector Gerner Det C+; 5. Pushcart Archer LAN C+
21: 1. Mike Cook SF B; 2. Sabata McCardell Det B; 3. Wattie Needham SF B; 4. Rip Madison Det B; 5. Tenley Bargot Ana B
22: 1. Frank Wright Pit B+; 2. Jerry Johnson NYA B+; 3. Carl Wilkins Cin B+; 4. Al Nettles Sea B; 5. Jack Smith NYN B
[Edited on 11-20-2015 by nuzzy62]
[Edited on 11-20-2015 by nuzzy62]
[Edited on 11-20-2015 by nuzzy62]
nuzzy62
2 San Diego
3 Minnesota
6 Anaheim
7 Texas, Pittsburgh
8 Seattle
11 Chicago, NYN
12 San Diego
14 Florida
15 Detroit, San Francisco
20 LAA
22 Cincinnati
27 NYA
35 LAN Yea me!
2161 Farm System of the Year
November 20, 2015 at 02:26PM View BBCode
1 Atlanta2 San Diego
3 Minnesota
6 Anaheim
7 Texas, Pittsburgh
8 Seattle
11 Chicago, NYN
12 San Diego
14 Florida
15 Detroit, San Francisco
20 LAA
22 Cincinnati
27 NYA
35 LAN Yea me!
FrosteeTBear
November 21, 2015 at 03:17AM View BBCode
Geez-I don't know-seems like my best farm system since I have been here..............did everybody put their starters back in the minors?!:puzzled::puzzled::lol::lol::lol:
nuzzy62
17: Tim Aleno, C LAN
18: 1. Bulldog Howse B-, LAN; 2. Dave Evans Tex C; 3. Les Donnels Cha C
19: Nobody
20: 1. George Taylor Cin B; 2. Joe Wood Det B-; 3. Jim Snipes NYA B-
21: 1. Ryne Brown LAA B+; 2. Charlie Brower NYA B+; 3. Julian Rebello Atl B-
22: 1. Eric Smith Atl A-; 2. Wally Mead SF A-; 3. Valmy Taylor Cha B+
Relief pitchers
17: 1. RJ Estrada NYN C;
18: 1. Johnny Gray NYA C+; 2. Del Stocker Fla B-; 3. Chippy Duffy NYA C
19: 1. Fritz Bench Cin B; 2. Germiko Hill LAN B; 3. Kent orsino NYA C+
20: 1. Bobby Cassidy NYA B; 2. Gary Irabu Cha C+; 3. Tommy Mays LAN C+
21: 1. Thumper Williams LAN B+; 2. Charley McGraner NYA B; 3. John Hungling Atl B-
22: 1. Hasty Pudding Fla B; 2. Scott Tate Min B-; 3. Oyster Delahanty NYA B-
Position players
17: 1. Jim Sargent Det C; 2. Alex Office SD C-; 3. Eddie Parrish Min C-; 4. Norm Ortiz Tex C; 5. Brad Clark NYA C
18: 1. Bucket Goldbullion Fla B-; 2. Frank Tincup Sea C+; 3. Pelham Callanhan Sea C+; 4. Dunlow Firebang Fla C+; 5. Greg Valentinetti LAA
19: 1. Mike Zick Cin B-; 2. Allen Gelbert Tex B-; 3. Lloyd Richardson Cha C+; 4. Bob Boone Cin B-; 5. Augie Closter LAA C+
20: 1. Floyd Dingman NYN B-; 2. Shoeless Daniels LAN B; 3. Lerton Smith Det B; 4. Dick Thrasher Fla B; 5. Dave DeSilva Ana B
21: 1. Hardie Landrum LAA B; 2. Joe Tracewski LAA B; 3. Joe saturia Pit B-; 4. Jim Abernathy NYA B-; 5. Pushcart Archer LAN B-
22: 1. Allan Fillmore Det B+; 2. Ames Madison Det B+; 3. Mike Cook SF B; 4. Tenley Bargot Ana B+; 5. Mario Walker Cin B+
[Edited on 12-2-2015 by nuzzy62]
2162 Prospects Report
December 01, 2015 at 11:25PM View BBCode
Starting Pitchers17: Tim Aleno, C LAN
18: 1. Bulldog Howse B-, LAN; 2. Dave Evans Tex C; 3. Les Donnels Cha C
19: Nobody
20: 1. George Taylor Cin B; 2. Joe Wood Det B-; 3. Jim Snipes NYA B-
21: 1. Ryne Brown LAA B+; 2. Charlie Brower NYA B+; 3. Julian Rebello Atl B-
22: 1. Eric Smith Atl A-; 2. Wally Mead SF A-; 3. Valmy Taylor Cha B+
Relief pitchers
17: 1. RJ Estrada NYN C;
18: 1. Johnny Gray NYA C+; 2. Del Stocker Fla B-; 3. Chippy Duffy NYA C
19: 1. Fritz Bench Cin B; 2. Germiko Hill LAN B; 3. Kent orsino NYA C+
20: 1. Bobby Cassidy NYA B; 2. Gary Irabu Cha C+; 3. Tommy Mays LAN C+
21: 1. Thumper Williams LAN B+; 2. Charley McGraner NYA B; 3. John Hungling Atl B-
22: 1. Hasty Pudding Fla B; 2. Scott Tate Min B-; 3. Oyster Delahanty NYA B-
Position players
17: 1. Jim Sargent Det C; 2. Alex Office SD C-; 3. Eddie Parrish Min C-; 4. Norm Ortiz Tex C; 5. Brad Clark NYA C
18: 1. Bucket Goldbullion Fla B-; 2. Frank Tincup Sea C+; 3. Pelham Callanhan Sea C+; 4. Dunlow Firebang Fla C+; 5. Greg Valentinetti LAA
19: 1. Mike Zick Cin B-; 2. Allen Gelbert Tex B-; 3. Lloyd Richardson Cha C+; 4. Bob Boone Cin B-; 5. Augie Closter LAA C+
20: 1. Floyd Dingman NYN B-; 2. Shoeless Daniels LAN B; 3. Lerton Smith Det B; 4. Dick Thrasher Fla B; 5. Dave DeSilva Ana B
21: 1. Hardie Landrum LAA B; 2. Joe Tracewski LAA B; 3. Joe saturia Pit B-; 4. Jim Abernathy NYA B-; 5. Pushcart Archer LAN B-
22: 1. Allan Fillmore Det B+; 2. Ames Madison Det B+; 3. Mike Cook SF B; 4. Tenley Bargot Ana B+; 5. Mario Walker Cin B+
[Edited on 12-2-2015 by nuzzy62]
nuzzy62
5 San Diego
6 Minnesota, San Francisco
7 Atlanta
8 Chicago, Seattle
10 Texas
12 New York (N)
19 Florida
20 Cincinnati
23 New York (A)
25 Detroit, Los Angeles (N)
26 Los Angeles (A) Congrats Alec!
2162 Farm System of the Year
December 02, 2015 at 03:12AM View BBCode
3 Anaheim, Pittsburgh5 San Diego
6 Minnesota, San Francisco
7 Atlanta
8 Chicago, Seattle
10 Texas
12 New York (N)
19 Florida
20 Cincinnati
23 New York (A)
25 Detroit, Los Angeles (N)
26 Los Angeles (A) Congrats Alec!
todd999430
Not often a team is top 2 in prospects and predicted to win their division. I'll take it. Winter is coming.
December 02, 2015 at 04:40AM View BBCode
Originally posted by nuzzy62
3 Anaheim, Pittsburgh
5 San Diego
6 Minnesota, San Francisco
7 Atlanta
8 Chicago, Seattle
10 Texas
12 New York (N)
19 Florida
20 Cincinnati
23 New York (A)
25 Detroit, Los Angeles (N)
26 Los Angeles (A) Congrats Alec!
Not often a team is top 2 in prospects and predicted to win their division. I'll take it. Winter is coming.
nuzzy62
17: 1. Jack Baldwin Min C
18: 1. Pepe Ramsey Min C
19: 1. Bob Vollmer Atl B; 2. Mark Wheatley LAA B-; 3. Earl Shea Det B-
20: 1. Phil Allen NYN B-; 2. Earl Coogan Sea B-; 3. Paddy Higbee SD C
21: 1. Nellie Stires Tex B; 2. Bradley Whipland Ana B; 3. Scruffy McGlyn LAN B-
22: 1. Dave Evans Tex A-; 2. Bulldog Howse Fla B+; 3. Tom Griffin Tex B
Relief Pitching
17: 1. Benjamin Caldwell Ana B-
18: 1. Tom Lauder Sea B-; 2. Syl Karow NYA C+; 3. Tommy Ock LAN C
19: 1. Wally Burnett Ana B-; 2. Joe Burrell Atl C+
20: 1. Evan Kimbrel Ana B-; 2. Elmo SZanto Ana B-; 3. Paul Robodoix Ana C+
21: 1. RJ Estrada NYN B; 2. Ferguson Figueroa Ana B-; 3. Jerry McElroy Det B-
22: 1. Johnny Gray NYA A-; 2. Chuck Wetherby Cha B; 3. Chippy Duffy NYA B+
Position players
17: 1. Alvin Hoffman NYN C+; 2. Heinie Cutright Tex C+; 3. Fritz Santana LAA C; 4. Scott Taylor Sd C; 5. Stu Mueller NYA C
18: 1. Jumbo Barry Atl C+; 2. Kaz Naro Ana B-; 3. Harry Whitt NYA C+; 4. Claude Oldtimer LAN C; 5. John Hogg LAA C
19: 1. AC Law Ana B; 2. Ramon Sauerbeck Atl C+; 3. MIke Burgermeister LAN; 4. Taylor Murphy Pit C+; 5. Joey Schall Atl C+
20: 1. Jim Radatz NYA B; 2. Honus Lindblad Tex B; 3. Ernie Schmidt Det B; 4. Johnny Quest LAN B-; 5. Don Taverez Atl B-
21: 1. Brian Brown Cin B; 2. Evan Donahey Det B; 3. Steve McQueen LAN B; 4. Tony Stellbauer SD B; 5. John Barry SF B
22: 1. Roberto Goldbullion Atl B+; 2. Greg Valeneinetti LAA B+; 3. Lefty Kessler Tex B+; 4. Frank Tincup Sea B; 5. Pellham Callanhan Sea B
[Edited on 1-19-2016 by nuzzy62]
2166 Prospects report
January 19, 2016 at 01:40AM View BBCode
Staring pitching17: 1. Jack Baldwin Min C
18: 1. Pepe Ramsey Min C
19: 1. Bob Vollmer Atl B; 2. Mark Wheatley LAA B-; 3. Earl Shea Det B-
20: 1. Phil Allen NYN B-; 2. Earl Coogan Sea B-; 3. Paddy Higbee SD C
21: 1. Nellie Stires Tex B; 2. Bradley Whipland Ana B; 3. Scruffy McGlyn LAN B-
22: 1. Dave Evans Tex A-; 2. Bulldog Howse Fla B+; 3. Tom Griffin Tex B
Relief Pitching
17: 1. Benjamin Caldwell Ana B-
18: 1. Tom Lauder Sea B-; 2. Syl Karow NYA C+; 3. Tommy Ock LAN C
19: 1. Wally Burnett Ana B-; 2. Joe Burrell Atl C+
20: 1. Evan Kimbrel Ana B-; 2. Elmo SZanto Ana B-; 3. Paul Robodoix Ana C+
21: 1. RJ Estrada NYN B; 2. Ferguson Figueroa Ana B-; 3. Jerry McElroy Det B-
22: 1. Johnny Gray NYA A-; 2. Chuck Wetherby Cha B; 3. Chippy Duffy NYA B+
Position players
17: 1. Alvin Hoffman NYN C+; 2. Heinie Cutright Tex C+; 3. Fritz Santana LAA C; 4. Scott Taylor Sd C; 5. Stu Mueller NYA C
18: 1. Jumbo Barry Atl C+; 2. Kaz Naro Ana B-; 3. Harry Whitt NYA C+; 4. Claude Oldtimer LAN C; 5. John Hogg LAA C
19: 1. AC Law Ana B; 2. Ramon Sauerbeck Atl C+; 3. MIke Burgermeister LAN; 4. Taylor Murphy Pit C+; 5. Joey Schall Atl C+
20: 1. Jim Radatz NYA B; 2. Honus Lindblad Tex B; 3. Ernie Schmidt Det B; 4. Johnny Quest LAN B-; 5. Don Taverez Atl B-
21: 1. Brian Brown Cin B; 2. Evan Donahey Det B; 3. Steve McQueen LAN B; 4. Tony Stellbauer SD B; 5. John Barry SF B
22: 1. Roberto Goldbullion Atl B+; 2. Greg Valeneinetti LAA B+; 3. Lefty Kessler Tex B+; 4. Frank Tincup Sea B; 5. Pellham Callanhan Sea B
[Edited on 1-19-2016 by nuzzy62]
nuzzy62
Pittsburgh 2
Chicago, Florida 3
Cincinnati 7
Detroit, Minnesota 10
Los Angeles A, Los Angeles N 12
New York N 17
New York A 20
Texas 24
Atlanta 29
Anaheim 37 CongratsBobbum
2166 Farm System of the Year
January 19, 2016 at 02:51AM View BBCode
San Francisco 1Pittsburgh 2
Chicago, Florida 3
Cincinnati 7
Detroit, Minnesota 10
Los Angeles A, Los Angeles N 12
New York N 17
New York A 20
Texas 24
Atlanta 29
Anaheim 37 CongratsBobbum
nuzzy62
For pitchers I value control more than power. All ages are based on the season start not OS. Health and Endurance are factored in for tie-breaks. Just because a player has the higher overall ranking doesn't mean they will be valued more highly in my system.
Starting pitching
17: 1. Perdue Cin C; 2. Toussaint Atl C; 3. Pack Cin C
18: 1. Hansen Min B; 2. Hensley Min C+; 3. Booker NYN C
19: 1. Leary Atl C+; 2. Anderson NYA B-; 3. Allard Atl C+
20: 1. Clemens Min B-; 2. Lucas Cin B-; 3. Siwy NYA C
21: 1. Hardaway Det B+; 2. Tomlin SD B+; 3. Atlanta LAN B
22: 1. Utley Det B+; 2. Nelson LAA B; 3. Scott SD B-
Relief Pitching
17: No one eligible
18: 1. Jackson Sea B; 2. McCarthy KC C+; 3. Winston SF C+
19: 1. Medina Min B-; 2. Eason Det B-; 3. Atkinson Ana C+
20: 1. Clark Atl B; 2. Abrams Det B; 3. Konieczny Min C
21: 1. Merritt Sd B-; 2. Gonzalez Tex B-; 3. Didier NYN B-
22: 1. Burbink SD B; 2. Moore Tex B; 3. Rainse Sd B
Position players
7 points for first then 5-3-2-1. RP over RC and then speed. I do value overall a bit more here than for pitchers.
17: 1. Boehringer Hou C+; 2. Carter Det; 3. Ramsay Sea; 4. Biggs Det C-; 5. Calvert Cin
18: 1. Harness Min C+; 2. Primerose Det C+; 3. Robinson Sea C+; 4. Frailing Cin C+; 5. Deering Atl C+
19: 1. Driscoll Det B-; 2. Hardtke Det B-; 3. Adizoia NYA C+; 4. Pittaro KC B-; 5. Cressand Cin C+
20: 1. Ferris KC B+; 2. Mercer NYA B-; 3. McDowell Sea B-; 4. Lindsay Cin B-; 5. Stillwell Min B-
21: 1. Zabel Hou B+; 2. Parrish Min B; 3. Cavanaugh LAA B; 4. Hickey tex B; 5. Judge Atl B
22: 1. Griffen Sea A-; 2. Speil Atl B+; 3. Rodas KC B; 4. Clack NYA B+; 5. Nolan Det B;
[Edited on 4-5-2016 by nuzzy62]
2172 Prospects' Report
April 05, 2016 at 01:58AM View BBCode
Points: 5 for first, 3 for second and 1 for third.For pitchers I value control more than power. All ages are based on the season start not OS. Health and Endurance are factored in for tie-breaks. Just because a player has the higher overall ranking doesn't mean they will be valued more highly in my system.
Starting pitching
17: 1. Perdue Cin C; 2. Toussaint Atl C; 3. Pack Cin C
18: 1. Hansen Min B; 2. Hensley Min C+; 3. Booker NYN C
19: 1. Leary Atl C+; 2. Anderson NYA B-; 3. Allard Atl C+
20: 1. Clemens Min B-; 2. Lucas Cin B-; 3. Siwy NYA C
21: 1. Hardaway Det B+; 2. Tomlin SD B+; 3. Atlanta LAN B
22: 1. Utley Det B+; 2. Nelson LAA B; 3. Scott SD B-
Relief Pitching
17: No one eligible
18: 1. Jackson Sea B; 2. McCarthy KC C+; 3. Winston SF C+
19: 1. Medina Min B-; 2. Eason Det B-; 3. Atkinson Ana C+
20: 1. Clark Atl B; 2. Abrams Det B; 3. Konieczny Min C
21: 1. Merritt Sd B-; 2. Gonzalez Tex B-; 3. Didier NYN B-
22: 1. Burbink SD B; 2. Moore Tex B; 3. Rainse Sd B
Position players
7 points for first then 5-3-2-1. RP over RC and then speed. I do value overall a bit more here than for pitchers.
17: 1. Boehringer Hou C+; 2. Carter Det; 3. Ramsay Sea; 4. Biggs Det C-; 5. Calvert Cin
18: 1. Harness Min C+; 2. Primerose Det C+; 3. Robinson Sea C+; 4. Frailing Cin C+; 5. Deering Atl C+
19: 1. Driscoll Det B-; 2. Hardtke Det B-; 3. Adizoia NYA C+; 4. Pittaro KC B-; 5. Cressand Cin C+
20: 1. Ferris KC B+; 2. Mercer NYA B-; 3. McDowell Sea B-; 4. Lindsay Cin B-; 5. Stillwell Min B-
21: 1. Zabel Hou B+; 2. Parrish Min B; 3. Cavanaugh LAA B; 4. Hickey tex B; 5. Judge Atl B
22: 1. Griffen Sea A-; 2. Speil Atl B+; 3. Rodas KC B; 4. Clack NYA B+; 5. Nolan Det B;
[Edited on 4-5-2016 by nuzzy62]
Hamilton2
My SP Elmer Taylor is OS 19, age 19, B- overall B/C+; he is most likely going to be a solid A+/A-, A overall SP. Your system rated Leary, Anderson, and Allard all ahead of Taylor, but he will have an entire extra season of improvements MORE than any of those three guys. The difference is easily worth 6 overall rating points and possibly more.
Meanwhile, you considered Hanson, Hensley, and Booker to each be worth something as "18 year olds" even though they are Taylor's same OS 19 age. He is already better than all three of them, and has the same number of impact season's left for improvement.
I guess I'm just using Taylor as an example of how your system is maybe overlooking the value of a prospect's OS age and is somewhat misleading with the categories that are there. :)
Why sit still when you could rock the boat?!!!!?
April 05, 2016 at 02:48AM View BBCode
Why do you not do this by OS age? The implication is that these guys get/have an extra season of improvements. But they don't.My SP Elmer Taylor is OS 19, age 19, B- overall B/C+; he is most likely going to be a solid A+/A-, A overall SP. Your system rated Leary, Anderson, and Allard all ahead of Taylor, but he will have an entire extra season of improvements MORE than any of those three guys. The difference is easily worth 6 overall rating points and possibly more.
Meanwhile, you considered Hanson, Hensley, and Booker to each be worth something as "18 year olds" even though they are Taylor's same OS 19 age. He is already better than all three of them, and has the same number of impact season's left for improvement.
I guess I'm just using Taylor as an example of how your system is maybe overlooking the value of a prospect's OS age and is somewhat misleading with the categories that are there. :)
Why sit still when you could rock the boat?!!!!?